10 Things You Need to Know Before Eating At Cold Stone Creamery (2024)

Ice cream shops are always joyful places. What could make a person happier than the sweet smell of fresh waffle cones and gallons of creamy, frozen goodness to choose from? Cold Stone Creamery figured out a way to top that with a unique in-store experience that makes any conehead's heart go pitter-patter. We've got the low-down on how the chain churns out those creamy concoctions.

1. Cold Stone ice cream was different from the beginning.

Donald and Susan Sutherland traveled around the world in search of the perfect ice cream and founded Cold Stone Creamery back in 1988. The first location was in Tempe, AZ, where they began serving their unique recipe, which falls between a hard-packed ice cream and soft serve.

10 Things You Need to Know Before Eating At Cold Stone Creamery (1)

2. The ice cream is made fresh daily.

How many scoop shops whip up their own flavors right in the store? Cold Stone's ice cream is made on the premises every day, and is categorized as "super premium" by industry standards—meaning it contains 12% to 14% butterfat, which gives it a uniquely creamy texture that sets it apart.

3. Each store has a very special countertop.

Keeping the product cold is extremely important in the ice cream business, but these shops have more than just freezers. A long slab of granite serves as the countertop at Cold Stone (hence the name), and is chilled to around 16 degrees F.

10 Things You Need to Know Before Eating At Cold Stone Creamery (5)

4. Their "toppings" are not just for sprinkling on top.

That granite stone comes in handy when it's time for customers to choose their mix-ins. Crew members put a big dollop of ice cream base right on the cold countertop and make a well with their spatula. A selection of mix-ins get nestled inside, then chopped and folded into the creamy mixture until they're evenly incorporated.

5. There are over 30 mix-ins to choose from.

In addition to the shop's signature creations, customers can opt to make their own concoctions with the impressive selection of toppings. You'll see everything from fresh fruit and candy-bar pieces to sponge cake and gooey brownies behind the counter. At around $.69 per topping, your sundae cost can get pretty steep if you're piling toppings on—one customer tried ordering every single mix-in and got what he asked for, for a total price of $28.90!

6. Staffers have to go through an "audition" process.

The employees aren't just there to mindlessly scoop all day—they're called "sundae artists" and when they interview, they have to impress higher-ups with an enthusiastic performance to prove that they can contribute to the "Entertainment Factor."

7. They might even sing for you.

Staffers are instructed to break into song when they receive a tip, and some crew members even come up with their own ditties for customers. Depending on your threshold for public embarrassment, that means you should either make sure to drop some change in the tip jar, or make sure to avoid eye contact at all costs.

8. The chain is home to the World's Biggest Ice Cream Social.

A scoop of ice cream is enough to bring a smile to any kid's face, but Cold Stone goes further to make dreams come true for youngsters in the U.S. In partnership with Make-a-Wish, the chain has hosted the World's Largest Ice Cream Social for several years, donating $1 to the charity for every "Love It" or "Gotta Have It" size treat sold over the course of a select month during the year.

10 Things You Need to Know Before Eating At Cold Stone Creamery (9)

9. They're famous for a half-baked flavor.

Everyone knows that cake and ice cream are a match made in heaven, but Cold Stone had a serious stroke of genius with one of it's most popular flavors—cake batter. Somehow they managed to get the essence of licking the bowl when baking a cake into our favorite frozen dessert. The flavor is featured in Birthday Cake Remix and other signature creations, and customers love it so much that they've recently added new baked good–inspired flavors for a limited time: Loaded Peanut Butter Batter, Rainbow Cookie Batter and Everything's Batter With Chocolate.

10. Cold Stone won't wreck your diet

Okay, so you probably want to steer clear of those decadent signature creations, but did you know that Cold Stone also has a frozen yogurt bar? Existing Cold Stone locations have added FroYo to the menu, with a similar setup as what you'll find at Pinkberry—but with all the awesome toppings you get with the ice cream.

PIN IT FOR LATER:

10 Things You Need to Know Before Eating At Cold Stone Creamery (11)

Follow Delish on Instagram.

10 Things You Need to Know Before Eating At Cold Stone Creamery (2024)

FAQs

10 Things You Need to Know Before Eating At Cold Stone Creamery? ›

For more than 30 years we've served up the finest, freshest ice cream, cakes, smoothies and shakes using only the highest quality ingredients, and of course, our signature process of preparing your custom ice cream creation on a frozen granite stone. Learn more about us at the links below!

What is special about Cold Stone Creamery? ›

For more than 30 years we've served up the finest, freshest ice cream, cakes, smoothies and shakes using only the highest quality ingredients, and of course, our signature process of preparing your custom ice cream creation on a frozen granite stone. Learn more about us at the links below!

What is the Cold Stone controversy? ›

Woman sues Cold Stone Creamery over lack of pistachios in pistachio ice cream. A New York federal judge has ruled that a woman's class action lawsuit complaining that the pistachio ice cream she ordered did not contain pistachios can go forward, The Associated Press reported.

Why is Cold Stone ice cream so thick? ›

Less air inside ice cream means less ice crystals upon freezing — and a creamier consistency for the final product. Once the cream is pulled from the fridge, it's combined with the flavor mix of choice in Cold Stone's in-house mixing machine. That mixer runs for exactly ten minutes — no more, no less.

What is Cold Stone's most popular ice cream flavor? ›

According to online ordering data, the top 10 ice cream flavors are:
  • French Vanilla.
  • Sweet Cream.
  • Cheesecake.
  • Coffee.
  • Strawberry.
  • Mint.
  • Classic Cookie Dough.
  • Cotton Candy.

Why did Cold Stone fail? ›

Numerous franchisees have been quoted saying Cold Stone's business model was “defective” and pushed the cost of running a store so high that it was difficult for individuals owners to make a profit.

Why do people like Cold Stone? ›

When it comes to unique, made-to-order ice cream desserts, no other brand offers customers what Cold Stone does. Our super-premium ice cream is made fresh in over 1,000 locations in the United States, and in hundreds of other locations around the world.

How long can Cold Stone ice cream last in the freezer? ›

To eat, or not to eat? Once opened, ice cream stays fresh for about six weeks when stored at zero degrees Fahrenheit. Unopened ice cream will stay fresh for two to three months in a zero-degree Fahrenheit freezer.

Why does Cold Stone throw ice cream? ›

So, the ice cream parlor company called “Cold Stone Creamery” and their staff decided to uplift their skills. They come up with the idea to impress and entertain their customer by performing an amazing show of throwing and catching the ice cream! It is so hilarious that you simply have to check it out!

What thickens ice cream? ›

Adding thickening agents, such as egg yolks, cornstarch, gelatin, tapioca starch, or even Junket tablets, enhances the texture and elevates the overall ice cream experience. Remember, making homemade ice cream is as much an art as it is a science.

What is the 3 most popular ice cream flavor? ›

The top five ice cream flavors that reign supreme are:
  • Vanilla.
  • Chocolate.
  • Strawberry.
  • Mint chocolate chip.
  • Cookies & cream.
Feb 14, 2024

What are the best mix-ins at Cold Stone? ›

For Mix-Ins™, brownies reigned supreme, followed closely by OREO® cookies, cookie dough, caramel and fudge. Cookies & Creamery™ took the first spot for ice cream cakes with Tall, Dark & Delicious™ coming in second place.

Is Cold Stone Creamery like it or love it? ›

Before any mix-ins are added, our individual portion sizes are referred to as: Like It ® - approximately 5 oz. Love It ® - approximately 8 oz. Gotta Have It ® - approximately 12 oz.

What does Cold Stone mix their ice cream on? ›

First, we make your ice cream fresh inside every store. Then we take your favorite ice cream flavor, add your choice of mix-ins, and finally we chop and fold it all together using two spades on a frozen granite stone.

What would be the advantages of buying a Cold Stone Creamery franchise? ›

The Top Reasons to Own a Cold Stone Creamery Franchise
  • A Beloved Brand with National Recognition. ...
  • Proven Model and Growth Potential. ...
  • A Unique and Customizable Product Offering. ...
  • Comprehensive Training and Ongoing Support. ...
  • A Community of Franchisees.

Is Cold Stone a type of ice cream? ›

Cold Stone Creamery is now the sixth best-selling brand of ice cream in the US. In 2008, Cold Stone opened its first European franchise in Copenhagen, Denmark.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arline Emard IV

Last Updated:

Views: 5864

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arline Emard IV

Birthday: 1996-07-10

Address: 8912 Hintz Shore, West Louie, AZ 69363-0747

Phone: +13454700762376

Job: Administration Technician

Hobby: Paintball, Horseback riding, Cycling, Running, Macrame, Playing musical instruments, Soapmaking

Introduction: My name is Arline Emard IV, I am a cheerful, gorgeous, colorful, joyous, excited, super, inquisitive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.