America's favorite ice cream flavors (2024)

Here we are in the heart of the summer, ice cream season! A YouGov poll inmid-July asked 1,000 U.S. adults about their ice cream preferences andhabits. Following are some of the key findings.

Summer is not the only time Americans consume ice cream. Eight in 10Americans consider it a year-round treat (80%), while one in six considerit only a summer treat (17%).

However, only 71% of Americans who have vanilla as their favorite flavoreat ice cream year-round, whereas 85% who have chocolate as their favoriteflavor are year-round ice cream consumers.

When asked to choose any ice cream flavors they like from a list of 21popular flavors and what their favorite flavor was, the flavor liked themost by Americans is vanilla ice cream (59%) followed by chocolate icecream (51%). Eleven percent of Americans rate vanilla as their favoriteflavor, and 10% chose chocolate as their favorite. Other crowd-pleaserflavors are strawberry (43%) and cookies and cream (43%), selected asfavorites by 6% and 7%, respectively. Mint chocolate chip and butter pecanchallenge vanilla and chocolate for favorite flavor (9% and 8%,respectively) even though neither is liked by more than 35% of Americans.

Regarding the 11% of Americas who chose vanilla as their favorite flavor,17% of those aged 18-29 call it their favorite, compared to only 5% ofthose aged 30-44. There is less variation by age for people who selectedchocolate as their favorite ice cream flavor, only varying between 9% and12% by age.

Only 3% of Americans say they don't like ice cream.

There are regional differences in preferences. Southerners like butterpecan ice cream the most (42%), while Midwesterners like chocolate chipcookie dough (44%) and caramel ice cream (41%). Northeasterners are morelikely to be fans of coffee ice cream (32%) and peanut butter ice cream(29%) than are people from any other region. Westerners are among the mostlikely to like vanilla ice cream overall (64%) and the least likely tochoose chocolate ice cream (43%) as a flavor they like.

When asked to choose between chocolate and vanilla ice cream, Americansprefer vanilla over chocolate by 49% to 43%. Vanilla wins by the biggestmargins in the Midwest (56% to 39%) and in the West (53% to 35%). Peopleliving in the South are more split on the question, and Northeasternersprefer chocolate (43% say vanilla, 50% chocolate).

When ordering ice cream, most Americans say two scoops is the sweet spot(60%).

For what to get the ice cream in, the largest percentage of Americansprefer a cup or bowl (44%), followed by a waffle cone (35%), a sugar cone(13%), and a cake cone (6%).

Top choices for ice cream toppings or mix-ins are hot fudge (preferred by43% of Americans), chocolate syrup (35%), caramel (34%), and whipped cream(34%). Just one in seven Americans dislike toppings on their ice cream(15%).

There are also regional differences when it comes to toppings.Northeasterners are more likely than people from any other region to saythey like sprinkles (32%), marshmallows (18%), or coconut (16%) asice-cream toppings. Midwesterners more like caramel (36%), brownie bites(25%), peanut butter cups (22%), candy bar bits (22%), and cookie dough(20%) when compared to people from other regions.