Healthy alternatives to store bought tomato sauce (2024)

Most of us like tomato sauce as a topper for pasta and pizza or baked into some favorite dishes like lasagna but did you know that many store-bought sauces contain a lot of hidden sugars? For a 2000-calorie daily diet, only 50 grams of sugar are recommended. They can be hiding in lots of places, so when you can cut back somewhere, it’s best to try.

In this post, we will look at some alternatives to using tomato sauce as well as share a recipe to make a healthier version of tomato sauce at home.

Some common brands of tomato sauce have higher sugar content per serving, which is only about ½ a cup of sauce. Here are a few popular brands and their added sugar content:

  1. Bertolli Tomato and Basil = 12 grams
  2. Prego Traditional = 10 grams
  3. Barilla Marinara = 9 grams
  4. Ragu Old World Style Traditional = 8 grams
  5. Newman’s Own Marinara = 7 grams
  6. Whole Foods 365 Marinara = 4 grams (Winner)

Source:spooniversity.com

Tomato-Free Substitutes

There are other reasons that someone might want to avoid tomatoes and sauce made from them. Tomatoes are acidic and can trigger heartburn or gastroesophageal reflux and promote inflammation so on top of hidden sugars, you might want to stay away from traditional tomato sauces for other health reasons. Here are a few ideas for “Nomato” sauce.

Carrot and Beet Sauce

Similar to marinara but with a different flavor, carrots, and beets offer a ton of nutrition and can be supplemented in many dishes that use tomato sauce. Try sauteeing the vegetables with onion, garlic, and olive oil, then blend to desired texture. Add seasonings to taste.

Eggplant Sauce

To create a tomato sauce substitute from eggplant, first, saute or roast it, and then remove the skin. Add olive oil and your preferred spices and herbs and then blend into a puree, adding water to reach a sauce consistency.

Still want tomato sauce? Here is a healthy sauce you can make from home with minimal ingredients and no added sugar. You can make and freeze them for future use as well.

Homemade Tomato Sauce

Ingredients:
  • ⅛ cup olive oil
  • 4 cloves of garlic
  • 2 large cans of whole plum tomatoes
  • 1 dried bay leaf
  • 1 large onion
  • Black pepper to taste (optional)
Preparation:
  1. In a small stockpot or large deep skillet, heat the oil until warm but not smoking.
  2. Add the garlic and cook only until lightly colored.
  3. Add the tomatoes and juice.
  4. Add the onion and bay leaf.
  5. Bring to a boil, then simmer for about 45 minutes, until the tomatoes break apart easily (then mash them with a potato masher or spatula to break them up).
  6. Remove the onion.
  7. Stir well. Add black pepper to taste.

The Great Tomato

Tomatoes are technically a fruit but are considered a vegetable for culinary purposes. They are high in nutrient content, low in calories, and rich in antioxidants. They are linked to many potential health benefits. So as long as they don’t worsen other conditions, they and sauces from them are a wonderful way to add flavor to your meals. Just be mindful of premade, store-bought versions that can have higher added sugar content.

Healthy alternatives to store bought tomato sauce (2024)

FAQs

Healthy alternatives to store bought tomato sauce? ›

Carrot and Beet Sauce

What if I don't have enough tomato sauce? ›

Substitute Tomato Paste For Tomato Sauce

If you have a can of tomato paste in your pantry, you are in luck—this is the best substitution for tomato sauce. All you need is the tomato paste and water. Mix together 1 part tomato paste and 1 part water until well blended. Then, season your "sauce" to taste.

Is jar tomato sauce healthy? ›

Jarred tomato sauce can be an excellent shortcut when you need help getting a meal on the table quickly. It can feel like a healthy no-brainer, but with a little sleuthing, we found that not all sauces are created equal—especially in terms of added sugar and salt.

What to put on pasta instead of tomato sauce? ›

Instead of red: 20 pasta sauces that aren't marinara
  1. 1 of 20. Alfredo. Tom McCorkle for The Washington Post via Getty Images. ...
  2. 2 of 20. Amatriciana. Keith Beaty/Toronto Star via Getty Images. ...
  3. 3 of 20. Béchamel. ...
  4. 4 of 20. Black truffle. ...
  5. 5 of 20. Bolognese. ...
  6. 6 of 20. Butternut squash. ...
  7. 7 of 20. Carbonara. ...
  8. 8 of 20. Cheese sauce.

What is a substitute for canned tomatoes in spaghetti sauce? ›

Mix 4 tablespoons of tomato paste with 1 1/2 cups of water , 1 1/2 tablespoons flour and 1 1/2 teaspoons sugar. It will be watery when “raw” but once added into a dish like Bolognese, it thickens as it cooks (it only takes 3 minutes to thicken). This makes 400 grams (14 oz) which equates to 1 standard can of tomato.

What is a healthy alternative to tomato sauce? ›

Carrot and Beet Sauce

Similar to marinara but with a different flavor, carrots, and beets offer a ton of nutrition and can be supplemented in many dishes that use tomato sauce. Try sauteeing the vegetables with onion, garlic, and olive oil, then blend to desired texture. Add seasonings to taste.

What is a good substitute for tomato sauce for acid reflux? ›

Tomato-free swap: Butternut squash-based sauce. A sauce with roasted squash provides a tasty, rich (but healthy!) alternative to a classic red sauce.

What is the healthiest pasta sauce to get? ›

If you are buying a jarred or canned sauce, choose a tomato-based (marinara) sauce rather than a creamy sauce. Creamy sauces usually have more saturated fat and calories. Eating too much saturated fat has been linked to heart disease. Tomato-based sauces also contain more nutrients like vitamin A and lycopene.

Is it OK to eat tomato sauce everyday? ›

Tomato sauce should be consumed sparingly. Despite being low in calories, with around 15 calories per tablespoon, a serving of tomato sauce will usually contain 160mg of sodium of the recommended 920mg per day. Many also come with various kinds of salts, vinegar and onion powder to make it even tastier.

Is packaged tomato sauce healthy? ›

It's fairly high in salt.

Most packaged ketchup products are also high in salt. If you're sensitive to salt, eating too much salt may contribute to high blood pressure, heart disease, and other health concerns ( 1 , 19 , 20 , 21 ).

What is a good substitute for store bought pasta sauce? ›

According to question, There are several delicious substitutes for store-bought pasta sauces. You can try making homemade marinara sauce using tomatoes, garlic, onions, and herbs. Pesto sauce made with basil, pine nuts, garlic, and Parmesan cheese is another excellent option.

What to put in spaghetti to make it taste better? ›

8 Ways to Elevate Canned Spaghetti Sauce
  1. 1 - Extra virgin olive oil. Adding a good amount of a flavorful olive oil will go a long way in infusing flavor into your sauce. ...
  2. 2 - Fresh garlic. ...
  3. 3 - Meat. ...
  4. 4 - Hot pepper flakes. ...
  5. 5 - Red wine. ...
  6. 6 - Fresh or dried herbs. ...
  7. 7 - Cheese. ...
  8. 8 - Cream and/or butter.
Feb 26, 2018

What to use on pizza instead of tomato sauce? ›

What can I use instead of pizza sauce?
  • White Base. White based pizzas are made many different ways but the most common is cheese (usually mozzarella but there's no white base rules to follow) straight onto the base followed by toppings. ...
  • BBQ Sauce. ...
  • Vegetable Purees. ...
  • Cheese Sauce/Rarebit. ...
  • Creme Fraiche.

What is a healthy substitute for canned tomatoes? ›

Thinned tomato paste.

Dilute this with equal parts water or broth (so mix ¼ cup tomato paste with ¼ chicken broth, for example, to replace ½ cup crushed tomatoes) to mimic a similar consistency to tomato sauce.

What to use instead of marinara sauce? ›

13 Marinara Sauce Substitutes You Can Find in Your Kitchen
SubstituteTexture (compared to marinara)Taste
Tomato soupThinner and smootherLess seasoned
Canned tomatoesThinnerLess intense tomato flavor
Tomato passataThinnerDistinctly potent tomato flavor
Spaghetti sauceThickerMeaty and rich
9 more rows
Jan 2, 2024

Is marinara the same as tomato sauce? ›

While the two sauces share many ingredients, the main difference is in the consistency and depth of flavor. Marinara is brighter, thinner, and more tomato forward than tomato sauce. Tomato sauce is thicker, creamier, and bears some similarity with gravy, hence why some Italians call it “Sunday gravy”.

What is a substitute for tomato sauce paste? ›

For every 1 tablespoon of tomato paste needed, use 3 tablespoons of tomato puree or sauce. Add the puree or sauce in place of the tomato paste and cook, stirring constantly, until the puree or sauce has reduced and thickened.

What to add to bland tomato sauce? ›

Boost the Acidity

Tomatoes are naturally acidic, but sometimes a jarred pasta sauce can lean too sweet, or just taste flat. Incorporating acids like lemon juice (and even zest) or red wine vinegar right before serving can round out your sauce.

How do you fix over reduced tomato sauce? ›

Since it's over reduced, it'll be too thick and probably dry, so add water until it reaches the consistency you like, then let it simmer for 10 minutes or so, taste and adjust the seasoning. When you over reduce a sauce all you've removed is water, so adding water back in can usually save the product.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Laurine Ryan

Last Updated:

Views: 6329

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Laurine Ryan

Birthday: 1994-12-23

Address: Suite 751 871 Lissette Throughway, West Kittie, NH 41603

Phone: +2366831109631

Job: Sales Producer

Hobby: Creative writing, Motor sports, Do it yourself, Skateboarding, Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Stand-up comedy

Introduction: My name is Laurine Ryan, I am a adorable, fair, graceful, spotless, gorgeous, homely, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.