“Overfermentation” — What is it and is it a Problem? – The Fermentation Association (2024)

By: KEFIRKO

Overfermentation is a phenomenon which is a result of fermentation that lasted too long or had too much culture in it. Read on to get more insight on it and some tips on how to avoid it.

Time is Important!

Usually overfermentation happens when we leave the culture to ferment longer than recommended. For milk kefir that means more than 24 hours and for water 48 hours. With kombucha things are a bit more complicated, since there are very different approaches on how long it should ferment, depending on the individual taste. In our opinion, to make kombucha a great tasting beverage, it’s best to ferment it for 7-10 days.

So, if you exceed the recommended time of fermentation, it’s quite possible your culture will overferment. How will you know if this happened? By the look and taste of it.

“Overfermentation” — What is it and is it a Problem? – The Fermentation Association (2)

The liquid that separates form thicker kefir is whey. It is rich with proteins.

Overfermented Kefir is More Potent

Just by the look you are able to see if overfermentation is happening in your milk kefir. It will become more curdled and you will see separation happening. The liquid whey will separate from more thicker kefir. Additional fermenting time will also change the taste, it will become more sour.

Water kefir will not change much in appearance. When water kefir is finished, it tastes a bit sweet still. If you prefer it more sour you can overferment it. If you leave it for a very long time it may become even to sour to drink.

The same is with kombucha. After long fermentation, it becomes more sour, even vinegar-like in taste. If you overferment kombucha you will also notice it becomes a bit more cloudy.

“Overfermentation” — What is it and is it a Problem? – The Fermentation Association (3)

If you like more sour kombucha just leave it to ferment longer, more than a week.

Why This Happens?

We already mentioned one important factor that leads to overfermentation – time. If you leave the culture in milk/water/tea too long, it will overferment.

This is also connected to temperature of the environment. Higher temperature accelerates the activity of the microorganisms in the ferment. You will notice that in warmer seasons or if you have very warm interior in cold season, the fermentation can be finished even in half time.

Too much culture for the amount of milk/water/tea you are using. If you have more microorganisms in the ferment it’s only logical they will need more food. If you keep the volume of your ferment the same all the time, but the cultures multiply, the ratio will change noticeably. Again the fermentation will be ready faster. Note, it’s not recommended to overcrowd the grains, take away extras regularly. This will ensure activity and well-being of your cultures.

What to do When You Overferment?

If this was not intentional, you probably will not like the taste of kefir or kombucha once it’s overfermented. Here are some ideas what to do with it:

MILK KEFIR

If it’s only slightly separated and you still like the taste, you can just stir it well then strain and use as always. But if the kefir is very curdled and dense, you will probably need a big colander, where you can gently stir the kefir and separate the grains.

If you don’t like the taste of overfermented kefir you can use it in smoothies or as ingredient in other dishes and baking recipes (pancakes with whey,brioche,muffins).

WATER KEFIR

You can’t do much to change the taste of water kefir once it gets too sour. You can add sugar or other sweeteners. But maybe using it in smoothies or even for baking, would be better idea (ciabatta).

“Overfermentation” — What is it and is it a Problem? – The Fermentation Association (4)

Water kefir gets more opaque if you ferment it for too long.

KOMBUCHA

The same as with water kefir, you can use the sour kombucha in the smoothies or other refreshing drinks.

You can also leave it to ferment even longer until it gets really sour and then use it as a kombucha vinegar. This means fermenting it a few weeks not just days longer. Some also use this very sour kombucha as a natural cleaning product.

IS OVERFERMENTATION PROBLEMATIC?

Overfermentation basically happens when the grains don’t have enough food, the content of sugar has disappeared. Once all the food is gone the cultures starve. If this happens very often it can pose a threat for the cultures and they may stop growing and multiplying or producing fermented beverage. With fermentation, it’s important to feed the cultures regularly and this ensures having them for a lifetime.

KEFIRKO is a company that designs products for fermentation enthusiasts making their own kefir at home. They make glass jars with specialty lids for making a kefir drink and kefir cheese. KEFIRKO launched their product on Kickstarter 6 years ago, an idea “born from noticing how kefir preparation at home can be quite messy and complicated. Not something most of us would gladly do every day.”

Related Posts

“Overfermentation” — What is it and is it a Problem? – The Fermentation Association (2024)

FAQs

“Overfermentation” — What is it and is it a Problem? – The Fermentation Association? ›

Overfermentation basically happens when the grains don't have enough food, the content of sugar has disappeared. Once all the food is gone the cultures starve. If this happens very often it can pose a threat for the cultures and they may stop growing and multiplying or producing fermented beverage.

What are the common problems encountered in the fermentation process? ›

Mushy ferments are often indication of improper fermentation due to a weak brine, too high a temperature during fermentation, uneven salt distribution or air pockets. Mushiness is caused by spoilage microorganisms, but pathogenic microorganism can also be present; it is best practice to discard.

What happens if you add too much milk to kefir grains? ›

If you use too much milk, the milk can go off before the kefir grains have a chance to ferment it though, so be sure to understand how much it can do, and gradually increase from there. To get lots of kefir quickly with just a few grains simply keep adding milk without straining.

Why is my milk kefir separating? ›

Too many grains and/or not enough milk. These both go hand in hand. A brew with too many kefir grains or not enough milk make for short work. This will cause separation far earlier than expected.

What are the effects of over fermentation? ›

When your dough is over-fermented, the scores will not “open up” during baking but instead will flatten and melt into the dough. Scores don't really open up. The resulting bread will be flat and not have a good oven spring. The crumb can look dense and compressed, especially towards the bottom of the loaf.

What causes failure in fermentation? ›

The Fermentation Temperature is too Hot or Too Cold: Wine yeast like to ferment between 70-75 degrees Fahrenheit--72 degrees being ideal. Fermentations that are too cool may become very sluggish and quite often will not ferment at all. Fermentations that are too warm can perform poorly as well.

Is overfermented kefir safe? ›

At this stage the grains are firmly lodged within the curds and can be challenging to differentiate grains from curds. Here is an idea what you can do when you have in your hands over fermented milk kefir. And Yes!, over cultured milk kefir is still okay to drink, albeit extremely sour.

Can drinking too much kefir be bad? ›

The bottom line. Adding kefir to your diet can be an easy and delicious way to increase your intake of probiotics. However, drinking too much can have several side effects, including digestive issues. It also contains carbs and a small amount of alcohol, so it may not be suitable for everyone.

How to tell if homemade kefir is bad? ›

You should also notice that the kefir smells a little sour/vinegary and possibly cheesy/yeasty. The milk will have thickened and it will no longer look like milk.

What is the best ratio of kefir to milk? ›

-Place 1 Tbsp kefir grains in a glass jar and fill with 1 cup fresh milk. The ratio of grains to milk should always be 1 tbsp to 1 cup, and can be increased if you'd like to make a bigger batch. Leave about an inch of room at the top to make room for carbonization and grain growth.

How do I know if I killed my kefir grains? ›

To know if your water kefir grains are dead, use them to ferment a new batch and repeat this cycle at least 4 times. If the grains are dead, the water will remain sweet, and there wouldn't be a sign of fermentation. Another way to know is the appearance of mold on the surface.

How much milk kefir should I drink per day? ›

Kefir is most often used by adults in doses of 400-500 mL by mouth daily for up to 4 weeks. Lower doses of 100-180 mL daily have been used for up to 12 weeks. Speak with a healthcare provider to find out what dose might be best for a specific condition.

Should you stir kefir while it is fermenting? ›

THE FERMENTATION PROCESS: Once activated, place your grains into 250ml of milk per 5g of milk kefir grains and cover your jar. If possible, try to stir your milk kefir mixture every 6 hours, at the very minimum, every 12 hours. You are looking for the consistency of the milk to change.

Should you take a break from kefir? ›

Although water kefir grains can be used to make back-to-back batches of water kefir, at some point most people will need to take a break. Cold temperatures greatly slow the culturing process, so the refrigerator is a good place to store grains when a break is necessary.

How long can I leave kefir to ferment? ›

The longer they ferment the more acidic your kefir will be and the lower it will be in lactose. I don't recommend fermenting for longer than 48 hours. Although these grains are acid tolerant, even they have their limits.

What can go wrong during fermentation? ›

These mistakes can lead to bad flavors, inconsistent results, and unsafe fermentation projects.
  • Not weighing your ingredients.
  • Using the wrong salt concentration.
  • Not keeping everything submerged.
  • Not fermenting for a long enough time.
  • Adding unnecessary ingredients.
Jan 12, 2021

What are the 7 factors that affect fermentation? ›

Temperature, pH, acidity, ethanol, sulfite and availability of nutrients are all important for the growth and metabolic activities of the lactic acid bacteria. The lactic acid bacteria are more fastidious in their growth requirements than the yeast.

What are 3 disadvantages of fermentation? ›

  • Less amount of energy is produced.
  • High amount of energy is lost as alcohol and lactate.
  • Some end product of Fermentation are toxic, eg ethanol is toxic to plants.
  • Accumulation of lactate in blood and tissues results to muscle fatigue.
Jun 6, 2016

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Last Updated:

Views: 5674

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Birthday: 1998-02-19

Address: 64841 Delmar Isle, North Wiley, OR 74073

Phone: +17844167847676

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: LARPing, Kitesurfing, Sewing, Digital arts, Sand art, Gardening, Dance

Introduction: My name is Amb. Frankie Simonis, I am a hilarious, enchanting, energetic, cooperative, innocent, cute, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.