Salt Dough Questions Answered (2024)

Salt dough is one of my favourite homemade materials to craft with because it is so easy to make and use. Here on Rainy Day Mum, we have two basic Salt Dough Recipes – a classic Salt Dough that can be dried in the oven or a microwave salt dough recipe that saves you so much time that you can make, dry and decorate salt dough ornaments all in one class or sitting! This is especially useful for some crafting with toddlers and preschoolers who don’t have any patience at all.

Salt Dough Questions Answered (1)

Whenever I share either salt dough recipe I get lots of questions about it so I thought I would put together the most common questions and answer them here for you. I’ve split this into two parts – these are common questions that apply to all salt dough and I also have a lot of questions about painting and sealing the dough which I will answer in a different post.

What You'll Find on This Page

How Do you Make Salt Dough?

Salt Dough Questions Answered (2)

This is the easiest one to answer – check out either of the recipes below – the microwave recipe or the classic recipe if you don’t have a microwave or have time to wait. Although the microwave recipe works just as well when all of the instructions are followed because it doesn’t use the microwave if I have the time I like to use the classic method.

How Long to Cook Salt Dough?

The length of time that you need to cook the dough for will depend on the thickness and size of the object that you are trying to dry.

Salt Dough Questions Answered (3)

If you have thin ornaments for the tree then in the oven they may only take an hour or two.

However, if you are drying something thicker like a sculpture or a candle holder then this will take much longer and it may be better for you to dry using the air drying method.

How do you make White Salt Dough?

We have an alternative recipethat is pure white and sparkles slightly without the use of glitter.

Although you need to make the mix for this Baker’s Clay in the pan it dries in the oven and looks really good especially for snowmen or other ornaments for the tree. It’s also great as it doesn’t use any salt to make it. Although the ingredients don’t taste very good at all!

Salt Dough Questions Answered (5)

The other way to make white salt dough is to follow our simple recipe that ensures you have a white dough to use or you could, of course, paint it using Acrylic Paint.

What flour do you need?

You need a flour with no raising agents in it so plain flour in the UK or all-purpose flour in the USA. We always buy the budget flour for making it up as it doesn’t have to be anything fancy.

It’s not advisable to use Self-Raising Flour as this will make it puff up as it dries out in the oven or in the microwave.

How do you Store your Finished Ornaments?

Finished ornaments are very susceptible to moisture as it’s one of the ways that you can reactive it if it dried out before you have finished a crafting session.

So storing in a damp place is not advised.

However, if you use a sealable container and add a small bag of silica gel – here’s our affiliate link to the best silica gel we have found to use for storing the Christmas decorations our kids have made over the years., rice or even a marshmallow the moisture will be absorbed by these and will prevent your salt dough going moist and mouldy.

Why does my Salt Dough Puff Up and How to Stop it Puffing Up!

There are two reasons why it will puff up.

If the oven is at a too hot a temperature – you need to make sure it is as low as possible. My home ovens lowest temperature is 75C which is perfect for slow drying of the salt dough.

If you find that your oven has the lowest temperature of above 150C then I would advise you to air dry your salt dough creations which will take considerably longer but will prevent the puffing up.

It may also puff up if you have used self-raising flour instead of plain or all-purpose flour.

Salt Dough Questions Answered (6)

Can you Air Dry Salt Dough?

Absolutely, in fact, it is the best way to make sure that you have no puffiness and avoid any oven accidents.

Top Tip for Classes and Groups

If you are using the salt dough with a group that meets weekly then create your ornaments one week and leave in a warm dry place and then decorate the following week.

Depending on the room temperature, humidity and thickness it may take from overnight to a week to dry out fully.

How can I tell that my Salt Dough is fully dry?

When dry has a consistent colour, if it looks “greasy” or when you touch it, it can be pressed it needs further drying.

For sculptures that are thick the outside will dry first and as long as you don’t “seal” it fully the moisture in the centre will continue to evaporate and dry out even more.

Can you make Salt Dough ahead of time?

You can but it will start to dry out but you could mix the correct quantities of salt and flour ready to add the water as the mixing takes very little time to do at all.

Why is the Salt Dough Bubbling in the Microwave!

This is because you are heating the dough too quickly – make sure that you follow the instructions on the microwave recipe exactly to avoid bubbling or burning.

Can you Eat it?

NO NO NO NO NO – okay just a few more – NO NO NO NO NO. If you have pets please make sure that the area where you are creating is fully cleaned as the quantity of salt in the dough is dangerous to them as well as to you.

But our Easy Bread Dough is ideal to create with – leave out the yeast and although it doesn’t taste great it will make shapes and is great for kneading.

How Long does it Last?

It can last an incredibly long time – if stored properly.

The best way to store it is outlined above however, you can also keep it out as long as it doesn’t get damp.

More Salt Dough Inspiration and Ideas

Fantastic Recipes to Try

Classic Recipe

Christmas Scented Recipe and Star Garland

Salt Dough Questions Answered (11)

Pin this Salt Dough Advice for when you need it

Salt Dough Questions Answered (12)
Salt Dough Questions Answered (2024)

FAQs

Can you overcook salt dough ornaments? ›

If you overcook them, they tend to bubble up.

How do I know if my salt dough ornaments are done? ›

Baking Salt Dough Ornaments

They are done when they are completely hard. If they start to brown then they are well done – and that's okay! Once completely hard take them out of the oven and let them cool completly.

Can you let salt dough ornaments air dry? ›

Salt dough is a great material for making basic sculptures and three dimensional craft projects. It is an all-natural alternative to commercial play dough and homemade air-dry clay. Your finished salt dough sculptures can either be air-dried or oven-dried to set.

How do you know when salt dough is baked enough? ›

Bake the dough at 250 degrees F or about 2 hours. You want to bake them until they're hardened. They will harden a little more once you remove them from the oven and let them cool but you want them to have a good hard texture before you remove them from the oven.

Why are my salt dough ornaments puffy? ›

Make sure your oven is set to 150°f. This is SUPER IMPORTANT. I have seen others use hotter temperatures but I haven't been able to do so without getting puffiness. So, plain all-purpose flour, 150ºf oven and 1/4 inch thickness = no puffy ornaments.

What happens if you forget salt in dough? ›

Without salt, your dough will rise faster than it normally would, leading to less flavor development and a weaker structure. To incorporate the salt, mix it with a few teaspoons of water. Return your dough to the mixer, tear it into three to six pieces, and drizzle the liquid on top.

What to seal salt dough ornaments with? ›

How do I preserve and store these Salt Dough Ornaments? In order to keep your ornaments and use them for several years, it is best to seal them. Painting them with acrylic paint, if you choose to, will begin the process. But a coat of Mod Podge or Acrylic sealer that is applied like a spray paint will be needed.

Why is my salt dough bubbling in the oven? ›

Overcooking the salt dough creations could lead to bubbles or cracks. After cooling out the salt dough creations are ready for painting. If you don't have an oven (like in a nursery), you can also just wait until the salt dough dries out over time. This salt dough recipe works for no bake as well.

What to do if salt dough is too sticky? ›

If your dough feels too sticky, you've likely added too much water. Go back to the mixing step and add a 4:1 mixture of flour and salt, a little at a time, until the dough is no longer sticky. You can also try rolling the dough out between sheets of parchment paper.

Does salt dough need to rest? ›

Knead dough for 10 minutes. Wrap and let rest for 20 minutes. Transfer dough to a floured work surface and knead until soft and pliable. Roll out to a thickness of 1/8 inch; cut desired festive shapes with cookie cutters.

Why did my salt dough ornaments crack? ›

Why are my salt dough ornaments cracking? If your ornaments crack during or after baking, try adding a bit more water to the dough next time or cooking at a slightly lower temperature for a longer period of time.

What is the fastest way to harden salt dough? ›

Salt dough drying tips
  1. Microwave. The quickest method to dry dough is in the microwave, but the dough will probably rise a bit. ...
  2. Oven. Alternatively, put the moulds into a cool oven. ...
  3. Air dry. Leave the moulds in a cool dry place for between 24-48 hours (thinner designs will dry quicker).
Jul 29, 2021

What if salt dough is too crumbly? ›

If the dough is crumbly or dry, just add a little more water. Knead the dough for 5-7 minutes, making sure all the ingredients are well worked through. Fun Fact: Once you've made your salt dough, you can refrigerate it for up to 5 days in an airtight container.

Why is my salt dough crumbling? ›

Salt dough is susceptible to moisture, meaning it will pull any moisture from the surrounding air. This causes your projects to turn soggy or even crumble.

Do salt dough ornaments go bad? ›

How Long do Salt Dough Ornaments Last? If you preserve your ornaments properly, salt dough can last for years. I have some dough ornaments from my childhood, so they would be at least 35 years old. They are still in great condition and there's been no disintegration whatsoever!

How long to cook salt dough ornaments? ›

Let salt dough ornaments air dry for 4-7 days (no-bake option), or bake on cookie sheet at 250°F for 1.5 to 2 hours or until all moisture is gone. Decorate salt dough ornaments with acrylic paint, glitter or other decorations of your choosing. Hang with ribbon or twine.

How long does it take salt dough too dry? ›

Salt dough drying tips
  1. Microwave. The quickest method to dry dough is in the microwave, but the dough will probably rise a bit. ...
  2. Oven. Alternatively, put the moulds into a cool oven. ...
  3. Air dry. Leave the moulds in a cool dry place for between 24-48 hours (thinner designs will dry quicker).
Jul 29, 2021

Can too much salt ruin dough? ›

If a large amount of salt (or sugar, which is also hygroscopic) were to be combined with a small amount of yeast and left for a long time it could, in theory, eventually rob the yeast of water to the degree that the yeast cells would begin to die off.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kareem Mueller DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6475

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kareem Mueller DO

Birthday: 1997-01-04

Address: Apt. 156 12935 Runolfsdottir Mission, Greenfort, MN 74384-6749

Phone: +16704982844747

Job: Corporate Administration Planner

Hobby: Mountain biking, Jewelry making, Stone skipping, Lacemaking, Knife making, Scrapbooking, Letterboxing

Introduction: My name is Kareem Mueller DO, I am a vivacious, super, thoughtful, excited, handsome, beautiful, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.