The Audi Q3 is a popular choice in SA's compact luxury SUV segment, offering a winning combination of comfort, sophistication, performance and efficiency. However, with a plethora of excellent competitors vying for your attention, should you commit to it? We take a look at five rivals that may sway you.
By Ané Albertse
Published: 25 March 2024, 11:46
Estimated Reading Time: 4 minutes
South Africans love their Audi Q3s, and why wouldn't they? It's a great-looking, easy-to-drive, sophisticated premium German SUV, and considering how expensive other premium SUVs are (the new Mercedes-Benz GLA has a starting price of R922 085!), the Q3 is very good value. But, if you are in the market for something in this segment and you want something different from the Q3, check out these great alternatives.
1. BMW X1
BMW's X1 should not be overlooked.
The closest rival to the Audi Q3 in terms of driving dynamics and brand perception is undoubtedly the BMW X1. The latest generation X1 has had a significant growth spurt, translating to a more spacious interior and a commanding on-road presence. It features a punchy and efficient turbocharged engine lineup, with a choice of petrol and diesel options. While the Audi offers a slightly more generous cargo area, the BMW counters with its renowned handling and a driver-centric cabin. BMW has also upped the ante in the reliability stakes. Read Chad's X1 review here.
Want to sell your car lightning-quick?Get an Instant Offeron your car now!
Find new or used BMW X1 models on AutoTrader
We are smitten with BMW's high-tech interiors.
- Starting price:R 753 045 (BMW X1 sDrive18i xLine)
- Key features:Excellent handling, spacious interior , multiple engine options
Alfa Romeo Tonale vs BMW X1 vs Audi Q3
2. Mini Cooper S Countryman Untamed Edition
Take a walk on the wild side with this Untamed Edition model!
Craving a touch more personality and a fun driving experience? Look no further than the BMW-owned Mini Cooper S Countryman Untamed Edition. This performance-oriented version of the Countryman offers a thrilling drive and agile handling. In the past, Minis weren't seen as very reliable cars, but the brand is working hard to change this perception and overseas customer satisfaction surveys reveal that Minis are not problematic cars anymore.While its slightly less practical than its rivals, this specific Countryman's other talents (especially its punchy 141kW performance from its 2.0-litre turbocharged engine!) more than makes up for this.
- Starting price:R 775 504 (Mini Cooper S Countryman Untamed Edition), but the Countryman's base price is R645 286.
- Key features:Fun, fast driving experience, stylish design, unique character.
Related: Everything you need to know about the MINI Cooper Countryman
3. Volkswagen T-Roc
The T-Roc is another winner in our books.
The Golf-based T-Roc emerges as a strong alternative to the Audi Q3, particularly for those seeking a stylish and practical option in a similar size range, and the T-Roc delivers a tech-rich,comfortable and well-equipped interior with decent cargo space for its size, and who doesn't love the coupé styling? It boasts a range of fuel-efficient petrol options, making it a practical and stylish choice for everyday driving. Read all our T-Roc Reviews here.
The T-Roc's interior layout is practical en user-friendly.
- Starting price:R608 100 (Volkswagen T-Roc 1.4TSI 110kW Design)
- Key features:Stylish design, comfortable interior, good value for money
Nissan Qashqai vs Volkswagen T-Roc vs Mazda CX-30: Which one is the best value for money?
4. Subaru Crosstrek
If you often travel on gravel and beyond, the Crosstrek may be your best bet.
The Subaru Crosstrek, which serves as a replacement for the XV, is one of the more off-road oriented Crossovers on this list, sporting an updated platform and a whole raft of comfort, tech, and convenience features. It's an all-wheel-drive model with good ground clearance and sexy outdoorsy looks, with semi-autonomous driving assistants thrown in as standard, making it exceptionally safe and easy to drive. Taye reviews it here.
We like the portrait-style layout of the touchscreen.
- Starting price: R591 000 (Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i L)
- Key features: Off-road capabilities, all-wheel drive, semi-self-driving kit, impressive spec sheet!
5. Volvo EX30
The EX30 is sure to suit your pocket if you're into EVs.
Thinking about getting an EV? The EX30 is one of SA's most affordable electric cars. This newcomer boasts a sleek and Scandinavian-inspired design, a spacious and minimalist interior crafted from sustainable materials, and a focus on comfort and safety - you can't beat Volvo's Pilot Assist for semi-autonomous driving! With a targeted driving range of around 400km on a single charge, the EX30 offers a practical option for everyday driving with zero tailpipe emissions.
We attended the local unveiling - click here to read more about it.
The minimalist Scandinavian design is even more pronounced in the EX30.
- Starting price:R775,900 (Volvo EX30 Core Single Motor).
- Key features:Electric powertrain, luxurious interior, focus on sustainability
Not keen on an EV? Go for the XC40 instead.
Related: Lexus UX vs Volvo XC40 vs Audi Q3 - running cost comparison
Other compact SUVs to consider in this price range
Go test drive the Lexus UX, Alfa Romeo Tonale, Audi Q2 and BMW X2 as well.
ENDS
