Long before the Instant Pot came on the scene as a master of multitasking, there was the humble Dutch oven.
With the exception of pressure-cooking, a Dutch oven can do everything a multi-cooker can do and then some: brown, boil, braise, bake, and deep-fry.
“A cast-iron Dutch oven will give you better results than an Instant Pot any day,” says Lance Nitahara, an assistant professor at the Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, N.Y. In fact, this one pot can replace your slow cooker, stock pot, pasta pot, loaf pan, and deep fryer.
And this type of cookware goes way back: Lewis and Clark carried Dutch ovens on their journey across the American West in the early 1800s, and you can still buy reproductions of the three-legged ovens they used. Today’s Dutch ovens look a lot nicer, though; most are enameled cast iron and come in a variety of colors. But they’re just as multifunctional, and they’re a good choice for simple tasks and more complicated recipes like braising meat, baking bread, cooking soups and stews, and deep-frying chicken.
More on Cookware
Best Dutch Ovens From CR's Tests
The Best Frying Pan for the Way You Cook
Best Copper Frying Pans from CR's Tests
Best Cast Iron Frying Pans From CR's Tests
These pots are ovenproof, so you can start cooking your meal on the stovetop and move it straight to the oven to finish. And because they’re so attractive, some cooks move the pot right to the table—on a trivet, of course—to serve.
In CR’s Dutch oven tests, we braise brisket, simmer sauces, and bake loaves of bread. We also note how fast it takes to bring room-temperature water to a near-boil and use a thermal camera to see if the pot heats evenly. Six of the Dutch ovens in our tests earn an Overall Score of Very Good or Excellent, and they’re great all-around choices. But a few are a bit better at certain tasks than others. Here are the standouts for browning, baking, braising, simmering sauces, and boiling water. For more on Dutch ovens, read our cookware buying guide and full cookware ratings.
Best Dutch Oven for Braising
Braising, in which you cook meat or vegetables partly submerged in liquid in a covered pot, is a good way to turn a tough cut of meat into a tender, delicious meal. In our braising tests, we cook brisket in the Dutch oven for 3½ hours. They all performed well on this test. “We didn’t see major differences,” says Cindy Fisher, who oversees our cookware tests. In addition to being great for braising, the Lodge below is one of the most affordable of the Dutch ovens we’ve tested—and it’s among the easiest to clean—so it clinches this spot.
Best Dutch Oven for Soups and Stews
When you’re cooking a stew or a thick soup like a chowder on the stovetop, you want a pan that heats evenly so there are no hot or cool spots and the food cooks evenly. To test that, we use a thermal camera to scan the bottom of the pan to make sure that the entire surface heats evenly. About half rise to the occasion, including the Cuisinart featured below, which is nicely priced.
Best Dutch Oven for Simmering Sauces
Our simmering test, during which we assess how well a pot can hold tomato sauce at a low simmer, proves to be a challenge for some models. Our lowest-rated model, the Tramontina, earns a Poor rating on this test because it didn’t heat the sauce evenly. None of the pots ace this test, and only one model, the Anolon Vesta featured below, earns a rating of Very Good. However, it’s a bit tricky to clean, which hurt its Overall Score.
Best Dutch Oven for Baking
In this test, we bake loaves of white bread made from frozen dough. (You may prefer to make your own dough, but we use store-bought for the sake of consistency.) The best breads from our tests have a crusty exterior and are nice and soft inside. The worst have a dense, heavy texture. We got impressive results from half of the Dutch ovens, including the Merten & Storck baking champ below, which earns an Excellent rating.
Best Dutch Oven for Boiling Water
All of the Dutch ovens are able to quickly heat 4 quarts of room-temperature water to a near-boil, earning scores of Very Good to Excellent on this test. The best heat water in less than 10 minutes, but even the slowest accomplish it in 12. So you can skip getting out a pasta pot and use a Dutch oven instead. The Le Creuset model below is one of the top performers in this test, and one of the easiest to clean.
How CR Tests Cookware
One of the keys to successful cooking is choosing the right tool for the job. On the “Consumer 101” TV show, Consumer Reports expert Sara Morrow shows host Jack Rico how CR tests cookware so that you can focus on perfecting your culinary skills.
Mary H.J. Farrell
As a senior editor at Consumer Reports for more than 15 years, Mary H.J. Farrell reported on all manner of vacuums and cookware, as well as microwaves, mixers, freezers, and fans. Starting in the mid-1990s, she held senior positions at People.com, MSNBC, and Ladies’ Home Journal. One of her earliest jobs was at Good Housekeeping.
