Are Subarus Reliable? [Here’s What We Think!] | FINN (2024)

• Subarus excel in safety, with models like the 2023 Solterra, 2024 WRX, Ascent, Legacy, and Crosstrek receiving high ratings from the IIHS and NHTSA.
• The Crosstrek, Legacy, and Outback are noted for their reliability, with low annual repair costs and infrequent severe repairs, while models like the Impreza, WRX, and Forester have more reported issues.
• Issues such as engine problems, failing oxygen sensors, Takata airbag recalls, transmission concerns, and rodent-attractive wiring can affect various Subaru models.

From sharing the love to catering to cute canines, Subaru’s reputation as a family brand for durability remains strong. Yet, gaining a larger perspective on the brand’s reliability requires a close look at how Subaru performs in several other areas. The following sources can shed light on how reliable Subarus truly are:

• J.D. Power dependability rewards
• FuelEconomy.gov’s fuel efficiency ratings
• Safety ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)
• Average repair costs reported by RepairPal
• Kelley Blue Book’s (KBB) 5-Year Cost to Own

These same resources can also inform reliability ratings for other automotive brands. For instance, if you are interested in BMW's reliability, you can extract the same information included below, but for BMW instead of Subaru. The same goes for any brand you’re interested in potentially buying.

Once you figure out whether Subarus are reliable, you may want to consider if you can buy a car with a credit card or if you’re better off financing. Until then, read on to learn how Subaru ranks in terms of cost of ownership, repair costs, dependability, and safety and fuel-efficiency ratings.

1. Safety features and ratings

Like Volvo, Subaru has a reputation for prioritizing the safety of its occupants. The following ratings from the NHTSA and IIHS demonstrate that commitment:

• 2023 Subaru Solterra: This model earned a Top Safety Pick+ rating from the IIHS for “Good” ratings in all categories, and the 2024 model earned a five-out-of-five-star overall safety rating from the NHTSA
• 2024 SubaruWRX: Five stars from the NHTSA and “Good” ratings in all categories from the IIHS make this a safe yet sporty Subaru sports car
• 2024 Subaru Ascent:This three-row SUV earns a 2023 Top Safety Pick+ rating from the IIHS and five out of five stars from the NHTSA
• 2024 Subaru Legacy: A previous Top Safety Pick winner, the latest Legacy model earns “Good” ratings in all categories except the Side: updated test (“Acceptable” rating) and a five-star overall safety rating from the NHTSA
• 2023 SubaruImpreza: This model earns “Good” ratings in all categories except the Side: updated test (“Poor” rating) from the IIHS and five stars from the NHTSA
• 2024 Subaru Crosstrek:The IIHS awarded the 2023 model a Top Safety Pick and rated the newest variant “Good” in all categories except the Side: updated test (“Acceptable” rating), which is matched by the NHTSA’s five-star overall safety rating

As you can see, the Subaru lineup performs well in safety tests, except for the updated test the IIHS performs for side impacts. However, these models all perform well in NHTSA testing environments.

2. Cost of ownership

Subaru models won several awards for low cost of ownership from KBB:

• 2023 Subaru Outback:First in the mid-size SUV/crossover segment, at $40,191 to own for five years
• 2023 Subaru Legacy:Cost of ownership over five years totals $38,196, putting it first in the mid-size car segment
• 2023 Subaru Forester:Second among compact SUV/crossover models at $39,834

On top of being safe to drive, Subarus are also easy on the wallet, which helps make them a premium choice among parents. You can also take advantage of the all-wheel drive capabilities, which is just icing on the cake.

3. Dependability

Two Subaru models earned recognition from J.D. Power in 2022. The 2022 SubaruImpreza won the award for best resale for the compact car segment. The 2022 Subaru BRZ also won for best resale for the compact sporty car segment.

4. Fuel efficiency

Comparing fuel-efficiency ratings for the Impreza, Legacy, Outback, Ascent, Crosstrek, Forester, and Solterra incorporates quite a few numbers. Below are the select Subaru models that perform well in fuel efficiency:

• 2024 Subaru LegacyAWD:27 city and 35 highway miles-per-gallon (MPG)
• 2024 Subaru OutbackAWD:26 city and 32 highway MPG
• 2024 Subaru Crosstrek:27 city and 34 highway MPG
• 2024 Subaru ForesterAWD: 26 city and 33 highway MPG
• 2024 SubaruImpreza:27 city and 34 highway MPG
• 2024 Subaru Ascent: 20 city and 26 highway MPG
• 2024 Subaru Solterra AWD: 114 city and 94 highway MPG-equivalent (MPGe)

The Solterra carries the Subaru badge into the future with the brand’s first major all-electric vehicle. With over 100 MPGe combined, it’s a contender across several customer bases. An excess of 200 miles of range also helps it tackle the tame pavement of everyday life.

5. Average repair costs

By the numbers, RepairPal ranks Subaru 14th out of 32 car brands, with a 3.5 out of five reliability rating. Average repair costs total $617 annually, with 0.3 visits to the shop. Subarus have a 13% chance that repairs are severe, a percentage higher than the average for all car brands.

Subaru wires suffer from rodent-attracting soy-based wiring that plagues many other brands using the same product. The following problems also haunt several Subaru models.

1. Engine issues

Besides the head gasket issues that can arise and quickly overheat an engine, Subaru engines can suffer from excessive oil consumption and cooling system issues. Oil can leak from the piston rings, camshaft, crankshaft, or other areas with poor seals. Failed knock sensors and catalytic converters can also cause check engine lights to appear.

2. Failing oxygen sensors

RepairPal highlights failing oxygen sensors as a common Subaru problem. Also known as O2 sensors, oxygen sensors assist the emissions system and can be the cause of a check engine light. The Forester and Outback models have issues with the front oxygen sensor, but often, a simple replacement fixes the problem.

3. Takata airbags

The NHTSA issued a massive recall for Takata airbags, and Subaru (among many other brands) was in the middle. It’s critical to replace these airbags, which can malfunction and potentially cause life-threatening issues in an accident. However, once the affected airbags have been replaced, Subaru owners shouldn’t experience any further issues.

4. Transmission concerns

Subarus incorporate a continuously variable transmission (CVT), which has come under fire for harsh acceleration, unintended acceleration, and several other related issues. The Transmission Control Unit can throw a coding error, which forces the clutch to engage prematurely. This CVT setup also suffers from shudders, shakes, jolts, and hesitation.

As you determine how to increase your credit score to lease a car, consider the following reliable Subarus. With a FINN car subscription, you can experience how reliable these vehicles are without having to gamble your hard-earned funds—or your credit score.

1. Subaru Crosstrek

Ranked first among compact SUVs, the Crosstrek earns a 4.5 out of five-star rating from RepairPal. Annual repair costs hit just under $500, about $45 monthly to budget for. The Crosstrek visits the repair shop about 0.1 times per year, with a 7% chance of a severe repair.

2. Subaru Legacy

As cliche as it sounds, the Subaru Legacy does uphold a tradition of reliability among midsize sedans. The Legacy earns a four out of five-star rating from RepairPal and only costs about $560 annually to maintain. With only 0.3 visits to the shop and an on-par 12% chance of a severe repair, the Legacy doesn’t require more attention than necessary regarding upkeep.

3. Subaru Outback

In addition to the Subaru Legacy, the Outback hails from a strong heritage of reliable wagons ready for off-road and on-road fun. RepairPal ranks the model tenth among 26 midsize SUVs, with an average annual repair cost of just over $600. This Subaru model visits the shop around 0.4 times annually, with 12% of those repairs at risk of being severe.

Some of the least reliable models include Subaru nameplates like the Impreza, WRX, and Forester. The Solterra and Ascent continue to establish their reputations as the brand irons out the kinks.

SubaruImpreza

The Impreza’s reliability score is ranked 33rd out of 36 compact cars by RepairPal, earning a 3.5 out of five-star rating. The average annual repair cost is $653, which isn’t terribly high, but there is a 17% chance of severe repairs. With many of the issues discussed above, including unintended acceleration, plaguing this model, it’s up to the newest model years to set the record straight.

SubaruWRX

Compared to the Impreza, the WRX receives a similar 3.5 out of five-star rating from RepairPal. However, the 14% chance of severe repairs isn’t exactly confidence-inspiring. Many WRX owners also report issues with a bad clutch plate that dances on the border of requiring a recall. Issues from previous generations of WRX models also transfer to the newer models, so it might be time for Subaru to deliver to its most loyal following with upcoming refreshes.

Subaru Forester

RepairPal ranks the Forester 21st out of 26 compact SUVs. The 13% chance of a severe repair and 0.4 visits to the repair shop don’t automatically make this model unreliable, but other Subaru models rank higher. Some of the most common problems associated with the Forester include a faulty front O2 sensor, a failed catalytic converter that illuminates the check engine dashboard light, and cooling system issues that lead to a head gasket failure.

Is Subaru as reliable as Toyota?

What is the average lifespan of a Subaru vehicle?

How safe are Subaru cars?

High reliability ratings often mean Subaru owners share the love in spreading the word about their favorite new models. Subarus certainly rank high in safety, cost of ownership, and dependability, with respectable fuel efficiency and average repair cost ratings as well. Whether you’ve been driving for one year or several years, a Subaru makes for a reliable vehicle.

If you’d like to experience the reliability of a Subaru, FINN car subscriptions can give you the behind-the-wheel time you need. Subscribe to a new car and pick from several Subaru models or other brands like Ford or Mazda, that you can have delivered straight to your door. FINN also offers flexible terms and a subscription payment that includes insurance, registration, maintenance, and depreciation. Find the Subaru model you’re looking for today with a FINN car subscription.

Final thoughts

How Reliable is Tesla?

Have you ever wondered how reliable a Tesla really is? This covers everything you need to know about Tesla's reliability, including tech and batteries.

Will Insurance Pay for a Rental Car During Repairs?

Paying out-of-pocket for a rental car can quickly drain your savings. Read on to determine if your insurance will pay for a rental car during repairs.

Should You Get a Prepaid Car Maintenance Plan?

Prepaid car maintenance plans help alleviate the financial burden of car ownership. Read on to discover if you should get a prepaid car maintenance plan.