Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (2024)

Welcome Guest Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (1)Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (2) Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (3)Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (4)
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (5)Reception-All Forums
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (6)Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (7)Life in General
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (8)Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (9)Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (10) Print
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (13) Topic: Flapjack experts please
Page:12Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (14)Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (15)
22/5/2014 at 1:28pm
Location:Greater Manchester
Outfit:Santa fe Style & Bai
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (17) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (18) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (19) Quote

Joined:11/4/2009

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (20)


Forum Posts:699

Site Reviews Total:8
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (21)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (22)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (23)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (24)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (25)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (26)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (27)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

Hi I have made yet another batch of my award winning flapjacks
BUT for the second time when I have taken them out of the baking tin after allowing to cool for 15 minutes some have crumbled
I can remould them as they are moist but why are they crumbling?
I follow the recipe but add a little bit more butter and syrup because the first ever batch I made were like bricks
The second batch when they crumbled I thought it was because of me adding a bit of water so rebaked them.

This the third batch I have only added a very small amount of extra syrup and butter
Help please

22/5/2014 at 2:18pm
Location:Shrewsbury
Outfit:Berghaus Air 6.1
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (29) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (30) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (31) Quote

Joined:12/4/2005

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (32)


Forum Posts:943

Site Reviews Total:8
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (33)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (34)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (35)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (36)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (37)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (38)
Site Reviews 2018:1Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (39)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:1

What recipe are you using? I use http://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/1148640/yummy-golden-syrup-flapjacks
To make them a bit more gooey add more syrup only.
Also what type of oven are you using, if it is a fan then make sure you lower the temperature and possibly give less cooking time.
Hope this helps.
Shirley
22/5/2014 at 2:21pm
Location:Ireland
Outfit:Tabbert da Vinci
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (41) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (42) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (43) Quote

Joined:03/6/2012

Standard Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (44)


Forum Posts:95

Site Reviews Total:3
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (45)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (46)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (47)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (48)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (49)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (50)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (51)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

Are you using different oatflakes than normal? Some brands seem to give a drier flapjack. I love gooey flapjacks, my mother's friend called them elephant's earwaxFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (52)

-------------
Shirley

22/5/2014 at 2:38pm
Location:Greater Manchester
Outfit:Santa fe Style & Bai
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (54) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (55) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (56) Quote

Joined:11/4/2009

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (57)


Forum Posts:699

Site Reviews Total:8
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (58)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (59)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (60)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (61)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (62)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (63)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (64)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (65)
22/5/2014 at 2:42pm
Location:Greater Manchester
Outfit:Santa fe Style & Bai
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (67) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (68) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (69) Quote

Joined:11/4/2009

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (70)


Forum Posts:699

Site Reviews Total:8
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (71)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (72)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (73)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (74)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (75)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (76)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (77)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

It Is a normal gas oven
Scotch porridge oats

Advertisem*nt

22/5/2014 at 2:45pm
Location:Greater Manchester
Outfit:Santa fe Style & Bai
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (79) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (80) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (81) Quote

Joined:11/4/2009

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (82)


Forum Posts:699

Site Reviews Total:8
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (83)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (84)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (85)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (86)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (87)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (88)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (89)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

125g Butter
125g Demerara sugar
5 tbsp. golden syrup 225g Scotts porage oats
1tbsp of cimmamin
over gas 5 bake for 20 mins and cool for 15
22/5/2014 at 3:24pm
Location:Ayrshire
Outfit:Trigano Tribute 669
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (91) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (92) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (93) Quote

Joined:24/3/2013

Gold Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (94)


Forum Posts:291

Site Reviews Total:0
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (95)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (96)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (97)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (98)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (99)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (100)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (101)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

I use the following recipe:

6oz butter
5oz Soft brown sugar
3 tbsp. golden syrup
12oz of porridge oats
1/2 tsp. baking powder.

The only time mine crumble are if I cut them too soon after they come out the oven.

I cook them for 15-20 at 160 degrees in the fan oven.

Sorry for the ounces - I'm old fashioned!x

-------------
Gillian

22/5/2014 at 3:28pm
Location:Derbyshire
Outfit:ElddisAvante462 Honda CRV SE2.2 i-Dtec
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (103) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (104) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (105) Quote

Joined:26/1/2006

Diamond Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (106)


Forum Posts:3025

Site Reviews Total:0
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (107)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (108)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (109)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (110)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (111)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (112)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (113)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

Just be careful what butter you use, some of the 'spreadable' varieties contain vegetable oil or added water and wont set properly in some baking recipes, best to use the old fashioned block butter without any additives.

Julia

-------------
Just love to be out amoungst Nature and Wildlife

Celebrating 37 years of Caravanning in 2019, Recently Considered Retiring, but Totally Addicted for Life!

22/5/2014 at 3:45pm
Location:Greater Manchester
Outfit:Santa fe Style & Bai
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (115) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (116) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (117) Quote

Joined:11/4/2009

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (118)


Forum Posts:699

Site Reviews Total:8
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (119)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (120)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (121)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (122)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (123)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (124)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (125)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

That could explain it!
I added a bit of the spreadable on each occasion.

Cutting / taking out of the tin while still warm
I gave them the 15 minutes maybe next time I will just leave them and then cut them out of the tin when COLD
Forth time perfect Hmmmm
Thank you everyone

22/5/2014 at 4:41pm
Location:Ayrshire
Outfit:Trigano Tribute 669
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (127) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (128) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (129) Quote

Joined:24/3/2013

Gold Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (130)


Forum Posts:291

Site Reviews Total:0
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (131)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (132)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (133)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (134)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (135)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (136)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (137)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

Quote: Originally posted by romany girl on 22/5/2014Just be careful what butter you use, some of the 'spreadable' varieties contain vegetable oil or added water and wont set properly in some baking recipes, best to use the old fashioned block butter without any additives.

Julia

Oh agree! From past experience, spreadable makes baking a disaster. Good old unsalted block butter for me. I bake wheat-free too - fraught with disaster lol!x

-------------
Gillian

Advertisem*nt

22/5/2014 at 6:26pm
Location:Norfolk
Outfit:Bailey Senatar Arizona
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (139) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (140) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (141) Quote

Joined:11/2/2007

Gold Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (142)


Forum Posts:405
Tent Reviews:1

Site Reviews Total:3
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (143)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (144)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (145)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (146)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (147)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (148)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (149)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

I cut mine whilst they are in the tin and still soft and then allow them to cool completely whilst still in the tin. I think this helps them to keep their shape.
22/5/2014 at 6:47pm
Location:
Outfit:
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (151) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (152) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (153) Quote

Joined:11/1/2007

Diamond Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (154)


Forum Posts:2328

Site Reviews Total:24
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (155)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (156)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (157)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (158)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (159)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (160)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (161)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

Has anyone tried soaking the oats prior to cooking to make the flapjacks more moist?

-------------
Ollie

2016
Monplaisir - Provence
Camping Les Gorges du Loup
22/5/2014 at 9:32pm
Location:
Outfit:
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (163) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (164) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (165) Quote

Joined:24/4/2013

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (166)


Forum Posts:666

Site Reviews Total:2
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (167)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (168)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (169)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (170)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (171)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (172)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (173)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

No, but if I add dried fruit I soak that in a cup of tea!
23/5/2014 at 3:20pm
Location:Ayrshire
Outfit:Trigano Tribute 669
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (175) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (176) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (177) Quote

Joined:24/3/2013

Gold Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (178)


Forum Posts:291

Site Reviews Total:0
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (179)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (180)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (181)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (182)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (183)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (184)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (185)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

While we're on the subject of baking - does anyone else here bake gluten or wheat free cakes or biccies? I'm at last having success with cakes and bakes, but not with biscuits!! They're always so awful - look like cow pats lol.

Anyone got any tips?x

-------------
Gillian

16/10/2015 at 7:01pm
Location:Greater Manchester
Outfit:Santa fe Style & Bai
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (187) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (188) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (189) Quote

Joined:11/4/2009

Platinum Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (190)


Forum Posts:699

Site Reviews Total:8
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (191)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (192)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (193)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (194)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (195)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (196)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (197)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

Two questions
Could I use greased baking paper in the tin then add the mix on top
then slice them up whilst in the tin and then pull the whole lot out of the tin when cold
would this help and stop the crumbling issue?

Added cornflakes to the latest batch = disaster
used 210 grams of oaks and 40 grams of cornflakes all mixed in the pan with everything else and baked
But turned out very dry and brittle when cold

I even added 6 table spoons of syrup and extra butter
should I have just added some cornflakes on top of the mixture when it was in the baking tray and before going into the oven?

Thanks

25/10/2015 at 9:41pm
Location:West Yorkshire
Outfit:Avondale Dart 556 6
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (199) View ProfileFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (200) ReplyFlapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (201) Quote

Joined:07/4/2009

Standard Member
Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (202)


Forum Posts:28

Site Reviews Total:0
Site Reviews 2024:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (203)
Site Reviews 2023:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (204)
Site Reviews 2022:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (205)
Site Reviews 2021:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (206)
Site Reviews 2020:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (207)
Site Reviews 2019:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (208)
Site Reviews 2018:0Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (209)
Site Nights 2024:0
Site Nights 2023:0
Site Nights 2022:0
Site Nights 2021:0
Site Nights 2020:0
Site Nights 2019:0
Site Nights 2018:0

6oz butter, 6 tablespoons syrup, 12 tables spoons oats.

Line pan with greaseproof.

Put mixture in and press down all over with a fork.

Cook about 200 ish for about 25 mins.

Take out of oven, cover with a teatowel and press down firmly all over the flapjack while still hot.

Leave to cool slightly, then slice.

This recipe is well over 100 yrs old and has been passed down in my grannies cookbook. Never fails!

X

Flapjack experts please (Life in General Forum) (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edwin Metz

Last Updated:

Views: 6098

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edwin Metz

Birthday: 1997-04-16

Address: 51593 Leanne Light, Kuphalmouth, DE 50012-5183

Phone: +639107620957

Job: Corporate Banking Technician

Hobby: Reading, scrapbook, role-playing games, Fishing, Fishing, Scuba diving, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Edwin Metz, I am a fair, energetic, helpful, brave, outstanding, nice, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.