Truck Bed Toppers vs Tonneau Covers | LINE-X (2024)

Truck toppers and tonneau covers are two types of truck bed cover options that are used to protect and cover the bed of your truck. These two types of truck bed covers have different functionality and are used for specific applications.

Tonneau covers are lightweight and blend in seamlessly to the truck. Truck toppers are rigid covers that offer more storage and even a place to catch a few Z’s. Deciding the best type of truck bed cover for your truck depends on your needs and what you use your truck for.

How To Pick a Truck Cover

No matter which truck bed covers you choose, each option will protect your gear from the elements and from potential theft. However, not all truck bed covers are created equally.

When you begin shopping for truck bed covers, identify what you want your truck bed cover to accomplish, and start there. Don’t second guess yourself by asking, “Are truck caps worth it?” Set aside your concerns and start with the research!

Identify the pros and cons of popular truck caps and tonneau covers to help you decide the best fit for your truck. A few questions to ask yourself during your purchase process are:

  • Do I want a soft or rigid version?
    • Both tonneau covers and bed caps come in soft and rigid versions. Soft cover options are less expensive, lighter weight, and easier to install. Rigid options are more secure but have a higher price tag and are heavier.
  • Do I want to carry tall items?
    • If you regularly carry a motorcycle or tall items like appliances or furniture in your truck bed, then a bed topper will not be a good fit.
  • Do I want to sleep in my truck bed?
    • Sure, you can sleep in a truck bed with a tonneau cover if you fold or roll it up, but it doesn’t offer the same security as a bed topper. For regular car campers, a truck bed topper is the way to go.
Pros and Cons of a Truck Topper

A truck bed topper, sometimes called a camper shell, is a hard-bodied and windowed section that is placed on top of your truck bed. Camper shells transform a typically exposed truck bed into a lockable, weatherproof space for storing precious items or cargo.

Truck toppers provide extra height and protection of cargo and can even be an additional place to sleep on a camping trip.Some truck bed toppers have window access on the sides. These access points can also be fitted with shelves to help you keep your gear organized.

However, truck toppers can be difficult to remove and reinstall on your own, so they usually stay in place once installed. Also, items that you need to place into your truck must be done from the back of the truck, and accessibility problems can occur when items shift during transit.

Pros and Cons of a Tonneau Cover

A tonneau cover is made to seal the back of your truck bed from the elements and protect anything you store within. A tonneau cover can be folded back to allow the truck to remain within its pickup-style open truck bed.

Available in both hard and soft materials, there are many material options for tonneau covers to choose from. These covers are perfect for transporting materials that need additional height, like furniture or bulky items, as the cover can roll back and expose the entire breadth of the truck bed.

However, you may ask yourself, “Is a tonneau cover worth it?” It just depends on how you want to use your truck bed. If you need to keep items out of the elements and you don’t want them in your truck’s cab, then yes, they are worth it. Some say tonneau covers can save gas, which is debatable. Some of the soft covers have a limited lifespan and can wear out quickly or become damaged. Soft tonneau covers certainly don’t have the same lifespan as a truck bed topper. If this is a concern, we recommend looking at rigid tonneau covers.

Tonneau Covers and Bed Toppers from LINE-X

While both covers have great functionality, remember that there is also a difference in appearance as well. A truck topper gives your truck the look of a larger SUV-type vehicle, and the tonneau cover retains the original look of a truck.

LINE-X offers many different tonneau cover options for your needs, including our Swift Soft Tonneau Cover. If you think a pickup truck topper is more appropriate, we have lots of great options, such as our Sport and Elite Truck Toppers. Select LINE-Xaccessoriescarry a Lifetime Warranty, so if something breaks, just take it back to your local LINE-X dealer for repair or replacement.

Reach out to your local LINE-X dealer to see what options are available. You can also request a quote online.

Truck Bed Toppers vs Tonneau Covers | LINE-X (2024)

FAQs

Which is better a truck cap or tonneau cover? ›

The choice between truck bed toppers and tonneau covers depends on your specific needs, budget, and style preferences. Toppers provide secure, versatile space for cargo or camping, while tonneau covers offer an aesthetically pleasing solution with easy access to the truck bed.

Who makes line x retractable tonneau covers? ›

This cover is manufactured by Bak Industries (same as Bakflip MX4).

What type of truck bed cover is best? ›

A fiberglass bed cover should last for many years, even if you use your truck for work every day of the week. Covers made of fiberglass look like they're part of your truck. Offering sleek style, many people prefer the way fiberglass covers look over other options.

What are the disadvantages of tonneau covers? ›

Cons of Tonneau Covers: While a tonneau cover can protect your cargo bed, it can also make it harder for you to access. Some covers can also take up space after they're installed, so you won't be able to haul as much cargo anyway.

Does a pickup get better mileage with a tonneau cover? ›

Tonneau covers help reduce wind resistance, and the less wind resistance your truck has, the better your miles-per-gallon will be. In fact, some tests have shown that a tonneau cover can improve fuel economy by as much as 10%. The type of tonneau cover you choose will have an impact on your savings.

What is the most waterproof truck bed cover? ›

Stowe's 2-in-1 tonneau cover and toolbox combo is the most waterproof truck bed cover system on the market.

Is it OK to go through car wash with tonneau cover? ›

We recommend that you remove your tonneau cover prior to going through a car wash that uses spinning brushes. There are a couple of reasons to avoid these car washes, chief among them the obvious possibility of a rolling brush damaging the top of the cover via abrasion.

What is better, soft or hard tonneau cover? ›

While each cover can protect from the weather and debris, hard covers are a bit stronger when it comes to durability. The heavier materials can handle more of a beating and are better at preventing theft and vandalism. Also, hard covers are a bit better than soft covers when you're talking about longevity and wear.

How much should you spend on a tonneau cover? ›

Generally, you can get a cover that fits your needs between $400 and $1,000 or so. How do I know what size tonneau cover I need? Tonneau covers are sorted by year, make, and model, but you'll still need to know your box length.

What is the most secure type of tonneau cover? ›

Painted one-piece tonneau covers are the most secure covers on the market. Their anti-theft design locks in a position that overlaps the tailgate, and the tailgate can only be opened if the cover is unlocked and in the upright position.

Does a tonneau cover increase resale value? ›

Yes, tonneau covers are worth the investment. They offer enhanced security for your cargo, improve gas mileage, and help maintain your truck's resale value by protecting the truck bed from damage.

Is a truck cap worth it? ›

Caps can increase the aerodynamics of your truck if done right – something that can help increase the fuel efficiency of your truck and save you money. Not only do truck caps protect the bed of your truck from the elements, but it provides a weatherproof space to haul and store items that aren't water or weatherproof.

Why do people put caps on trucks? ›

A truck cap or cover helps to reduce drag by making the back of your truck more streamlined. This shape makes it easier for the air to flow over the truck without slowing it down. By reducing drag, a truck cap or cover can improve the aerodynamics of your vehicle, which can in turn promote better fuel efficiency.

Does a tonneau cover add value? ›

Yes, tonneau covers are worth the investment. They offer enhanced security for your cargo, improve gas mileage, and help maintain your truck's resale value by protecting the truck bed from damage.

Are truck caps safe? ›

Hardtop truck caps also provide an added level of security, with reinforced locks and a sturdy design that will keep your cargo safe from theft and weather damage. In addition to the added protection, hard-top truck caps also offer other great features.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Sen. Ignacio Ratke

Last Updated:

Views: 6060

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Sen. Ignacio Ratke

Birthday: 1999-05-27

Address: Apt. 171 8116 Bailey Via, Roberthaven, GA 58289

Phone: +2585395768220

Job: Lead Liaison

Hobby: Lockpicking, LARPing, Lego building, Lapidary, Macrame, Book restoration, Bodybuilding

Introduction: My name is Sen. Ignacio Ratke, I am a adventurous, zealous, outstanding, agreeable, precious, excited, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.