What’s the Difference Between Hotcakes, Pancakes, and Flapjacks? - SAPJACK (2024)

What’s the Difference Between Hotcakes, Pancakes, and Flapjacks? - SAPJACK (1)

All Stories Sweet Nothings

What’s batter than sinking your teeth into that first doughy and delicious bite of a pancake drizzled in pure maple syrup? The answer is nothing. There is indeed nothing better than that feeling of the first flapjack.

It’s the reason we celebrate pancakes as a go-to meal in the morning, and why some people make breakfast for dinner. Pancakes are delicious. Plain and simple. At least our crew likes to think so.

It’s also the reason why each year in the US we come together to celebrate the pancake in all its glory — there’s National Pancake Day, which occurs on March 1st this year. And then, of course, there’s National Flapjack Day — which occurs each year on March 7th.

Apparently, there’s even a National Pancake Day sometime in September. A tasty treat like this deserves to be celebrated on more than one occasion!

So, all of this sweet talk about pancakes has our crew wondering — what’s the story with pancakes? Where did they come from? And why do some people call them flapjacks, while others call them hotcakes and so on and so on? Here’s what we came up with.

Flapjacks vs. Pancakes vs. Hotcakes

First, let’s settle the debate. Flapjacks, pancakes, and hotcakes are all essentially the same thing. Delicious.

The nuance in naming exists depending on where you live and the method in which you prepare it. For instance, folks from the South and Southeast call them flapjacks, while people from the West, North, and even the East tend to call them pancakes. Some states have entirely different names for pancakes altogether. And don’t even get us started on the differences across the pond in the UK.

Here’s a more thorough explanation of the difference between Hotcakes, Pancakes, and Flapjacks in the US.

  • What is a Pancake? — By definition, a pancake is “a thin, flat cake of batter, usually fried and turned in a pan.” Typically prepared with flour, eggs, milk, butter and sometimes baking soda, pancakes are usually eaten with syrup or rolled up with a filling.
  • What is a Flapjack? Flapjacks are pancakes (unless you live in the UK). The folks at The Kitchen Community do a great job of explaining in more detail the true differences between flapjacks and pancakes across cultures.
  • What is a Hotcake? It’s a pancake. Our crew Googled it and the definition of a hotcake is in fact “a pancake.” There is, however, a subtle difference on how you prepare a hotcake versus a pancake. Generally, pancakes are wide and have a fluffy texture, whereas the hotcakes tend to bethicker and denser.

Our crew fell so far down the rabbit hole of pancakes, that we discovered there are way more names for pancakes than most folks realize.

See Also
Flapjack

There are…pancakes, flapjacks, griddle cakes, hotcakes, batter cakes, crepes, galettes, johnnycakes, blintzes, blinis, and our personal favorite…slapjacks. The list actually goes on and on.

Now that we’ve settled the old pancakes vs. flapjacks vs. hotcakes debate, our crew is curious about one very important thing…

WHO INVENTED THE PANCAKE?

Was it the Romans? Or maybe it was a man named Johnny?

Where else to turn for the most accurate info on all things pancakes than National Geographic.

According to Hot Off The Griddle, Here’s the History of Pancakes, our prehistoric ancestors may have in fact indulged in pancakes.

Analyses of starch grains on 30,000-year-old grinding tools suggest that Stone Age cooks were making flour out of cattails and ferns—which, researchers guess, was likely mixed with water and baked on a hot, possibly greased, rock.”

That sure sounds like a pancake to us. While the exact date, time, and person are almost impossible to find, the research from Nat Geo shows pancakes have been around for a very long time.

Whatever the age of the primal pancake, it’s clearly an ancient form of food, as evidenced by its ubiquity in cultural traditions across the globe.”

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING SWEET TO POUR ON YOUR PANCAKES?

  • Grade A Amber Maple Syrup

    $7.99$9.99

    Buy Now

Share this: Facebook Twitter

More stories like this

The Best Roasted Vegetables to Mix with Maple Syrup Love maple syrup? Love roasted vegetables? Behold…some seriously delicious dishes featuring roasted vegetables with maple syrup.

READ MORE

3 Maple Syrup Cookie Recipes That Go Great with a Glass of Milk Pour a tall glass of milk and enjoy any one of these maple syrup cookie recipes – from classic pecan, ginger, or a unique bacon twist.

READ MORE

Waffle History 101: Where Do Waffles Come From and So Much More! Want to know the history of waffles? We’ve got all the waffle facts you can swallow – from origins to weird pairings and more!

READ MORE

What’s the Difference Between Hotcakes, Pancakes, and Flapjacks? - SAPJACK (2024)

FAQs

What is the difference between hotcakes pancakes and flapjacks? ›

While flapjacks is an informal nickname for pancakes, some people may use the terms hotcakes and griddlecakes to refer to specific types of pancakes. In the UK, the word flapjack refers to something entirely different—a baked good made from oats that resembles a granola bar.

What's the difference between pancakes, flapjacks, and Johnny Cakes? ›

You'll hear pancakes more in the north and flapjacks in the south, but there are exceptions such as the Flapjack Shack in Traverse City, Michigan. Now, what's a Johnny cake? A Johnnycake is a cornmeal flatbread, big in New England.

Is a flapjack just a pancake? ›

In the U.S., pancakes and flapjacks are considered the same thing. Across the pond, though, the flapjack is typically baked on a tray. “A flapjack is much like a Rice Krispie Treat in the fact that it is a bar,” said Kim Mitchell, local chef.

What's the difference between pancake mix and flapjack mix? ›

Ingredients: British flapjacks are made with rolled oats, butter, and brown sugar. Additional fillings like currants, dried fruit, nuts, coconut, or chocolate chips may also be added. The main ingredients in British pancake batter are flour, eggs, milk, and butter.

Why is a flapjack called a flapjack? ›

The term 'flapjack' was first used in the early 1600's in England. 'Flap' refers to a flat cake and 'Jack' refers to an ordinary common man. In other words, the term summarises a simplistic flat cake, made with humble and accessible ingredients.

What are three types of pancakes? ›

If you want to diverge from the standard pancake recipe, take your pick from the different types of pancakes around the world below.
  • French Crêpes. ...
  • American-Style Pancakes. ...
  • Scotch Pancakes. ...
  • Indonesian Serabi. ...
  • Russian Blinis. ...
  • Moroccan Msem*n. ...
  • Danish Aebleskiver. ...
  • Irish Boxty.

Why hotcakes and not pancakes? ›

Those who believe these delights should be identified differently mention the specific difference in cooking method, where hotcake is a type of griddle cake cooked for a longer time, thus having a browner surface. Some would also say that pancakes are rather thin, while hotcakes are significantly thicker.

What's the difference between hotcakes and Hoecakes? ›

Most notably, pancakes are made with flour and sugar, while Johnny cakes and hoecakes are both made with cornmeal -- though hoecakes do occasionally contain a small amount of sugar as well. This ultimately impacts everything from the flavor of the flat cakes to how they are served and what they are served with.

Which came first pancakes or flapjacks? ›

People began using the word “pancake” during the 15th century, and the word became standard in 19th century America. Previously, people referred to them as Indian cakes, hoe cakes, johnnycakes, journey cakes, buckwheat cakes, griddle cakes, and flapjacks.

What is flapjack called in America? ›

In North America, Flapjacks and Pancakes Mean the Same Thing

While the latter feels somehow less formal (probably because "pancake" functions more descriptively), there's nothing to really distinguish them.

Why did they stop making flapjack? ›

Cartoon Network's reasoning for canceling the show was because Flapjack didn't match with its new lineup of shows for a young male-targeted demographic. The inspiration from The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack was obvious within the world of cartoon animated shows for the next 10 years.

What states call pancakes flapjacks? ›

Some of our favorite word wars include: flapjacks (North Carolina) vs. pancake (everywhere else); dropped eggs (New England) vs. poached eggs (everywhere else); a cabinet (Rhode Island) vs. a milkshake (everywhere else); a clicker (New England) vs.

What's the difference between pancakes, hotcakes, and flapjacks? ›

Flapjacks, pancakes, and hotcakes are all essentially the same thing. Delicious. The nuance in naming exists depending on where you live and the method in which you prepare it.

What are pancakes called in the south? ›

In the South, pancakes are interchangeably called hotcakes, griddlecakes, and flapjacks, though British flapjacks are made with rolled oats cooked in the oven. In the U.S., pancakes are made with flour, eggs, butter, and milk, and cooked on a griddle or frying pan to form leavened flat cakes.

Can you substitute golden syrup for honey in flapjacks? ›

It can be used wherever honey is used, providing a lesser flavour spectrum but saving rather a lot of cost; this would include on porridge, pancakes and waffles, in flapjacks, ginger cakes and similar. To really showcase this ingredient, try making our golden syrup dumplings.

Why are McDonald's hotcakes not called pancakes? ›

McDonald's has been coy, responding to a customer on Twitter that "hotcakes" is just the term they "prefer," but we'd guess it probably has something to do with the term being more popular when the item was first introduced.

What is the American equivalent of flapjack? ›

In the US, a flapjack is a less common way of saying "pancake"; in the UK, it's a chewy, sweet granola bar.

What state calls pancakes flapjacks? ›

Some of our favorite word wars include: flapjacks (North Carolina) vs. pancake (everywhere else); dropped eggs (New England) vs.

Do Americans call flapjacks pancakes? ›

In the United States and Canada, "flapjack" is a widely-known but lesser-used term for pancake.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kieth Sipes

Last Updated:

Views: 6558

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kieth Sipes

Birthday: 2001-04-14

Address: Suite 492 62479 Champlin Loop, South Catrice, MS 57271

Phone: +9663362133320

Job: District Sales Analyst

Hobby: Digital arts, Dance, Ghost hunting, Worldbuilding, Kayaking, Table tennis, 3D printing

Introduction: My name is Kieth Sipes, I am a zany, rich, courageous, powerful, faithful, jolly, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.